Mattress Guide: Stearns and Foster vs Tempurpedic

Two of the most well known and established mattress brands in the industry are Stearns and Foster and Tempurpedic. However, did you know they’re actually owned by the same company, the huge mattress conglomerate known as Tempur Sealy?

But don’t let their mutual ownership fool you. Though they may have the same parent company, these two brands offer significantly distinct mattresses that are suited to different kinds of sleepers.

Let’s take a look at both brands and see how they stack in some of the most crucial criteria for judging mattresses: supportiveness, durability and, most importantly of all, customer satisfaction.

Stearns and Foster vs Tempurpedic:

Company Overview: Stearns and Foster

One of the oldest mattress companies on the market, Stearns and Foster, has been in business for more than 150 years.

In addition to being one of the oldest mattress brands, Stearns and Foster also leverage their many years of mattress sales and expertise to position itself as a luxury brand. They frequently tout their luxury craftsmanship and offer high-profile, hybrid designs that many customers find comfortable.

Company Overview: Tempurpedic

Tempurpedic was the brand that pioneered the memory-foam mattress, which has since taken the mattress world by storm.

Though the memory-foam movement has become widespread across the industry, Tempurpedic has maintained its reputation as one of the best memory foam mattresses available by providing customers with a wide range of options designed to suit almost every kind of sleeper.

Mattress Supportiveness

A mattress’s supportiveness is one of the first and most fundamental things customers take note of. If your mattress doesn’t properly support your body or sleeping style, you’ll wake up feeling uncomfortable in the morning, and could even carry that feeling with you throughout the day.

Let’s take a look at how much support both Stearns and Foster and Tempurpedic offer.

Stearns and Foster Mattress Supportiveness

Overall, most customers experience a good degree of support from Stearns and Foster mattresses.

It’s worth noting that some people, particularly those on the heavier side, have reported that they experience some dipping, where the mattress begins to sink in a little and is no longer as firm. While it is not a huge concern with Stearns and Foster, it is especially a risk along the outside edges of the mattress.

Tempurpedic Mattress Supportiveness

Tempurpedic mattresses tend to score better than Stearns and Foster when it comes to supportiveness.

They provide a wide range of firmness options, which allows the customer to find the one that makes sense for their body and sleeping patterns. Tempurpedic mattresses also rank well in terms of edge support, particularly in the models that have pocketed coil support. But again, customers who are heavier or have a large frame may experience some slight dipping along the edges of the mattress.

Mattress Durability

Durability is one of the most important factors that customers look for in a mattress. Mattresses are large and expensive purchases, so finding one that will work well and remain comfortable and supportive for years to come is crucial.

Let’s look at how each of these brands stacks up in terms of durability.

Stearns and Foster Mattress Durability

While Stearns and Foster’s mattresses offer many advantages, durability is actually one area where customers have reported some issues in the past. Many people report some sagging over a long period, and some have experienced dipping or sagging in the short-term as well.

One potential reason could be the comfort material that Stearns and Foster use on the top of their mattresses. While it’s softer and provides more comfort, it can also lead to more dipping than other types of mattresses.

Tempurpedic Mattress Durability

When it comes to holding up over time, Tempurpedic mattresses tend to fare better than Stearns and Foster. No mattress will last forever, but Tempurpedic have proven to be more durable than average and last longer than many other brands.

As mentioned previously, it’s worth noting here that Tempurpedic offers a wide range of options, and firmer Tempurpedics tend to last longest and perform best in terms of durability.

Customer Satisfaction with Stearns and Foster

As mentioned above, the biggest issues that Stearns and Foster tend to have is with the durability of their mattresses, and this issue frequently drags down customers’ overall satisfaction with the brand. While some dipping or edge-sagging is not uncommon among pillow-top mattresses, customers tend to expect more from Stearns and Foster because of its status as a luxury brand and its accompanying price points.


Overall Tempurpedic mattresses are quite highly-rated and provide a high degree of satisfaction to their customers. One of the biggest issues that customers have with Tempurpedic is the price.

While they perform quite well by most metrics and are rated highly, their price points are also on the higher end of the spectrum. Some customers are happy to pay a premium to get a mattress from the company that pioneered the memory foam movement, yet others prefer to go for comparable brands that come at lower prices.

Two Different Types of Mattress

Stearns and Foster and Tempurpedic are two very different mattresses: the first specializes in pillowtop mattresses while the latter is known for their memory foam.

While Tempurpedic tends to perform better on many of the metrics used to measure mattress satisfaction, which one is right for you will depend on a number of factors, including your body type and sleeping style.

At Mattressville we offer both brands, along with a wide range of other mattresses, and our staff can help you select the one that’s right for you.

To learn more about the difference between Stearns and Foster and Tempurpedic mattresses, call Mattressville at 905-212-7722, or contact us here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.